During the end of last week and the beginning of this week we watched the documentary Sound and Fury. I enjoyed the film and the actions portrayed in it but there were some things I absolutely hated.
Heather is a five year old girl who can already talk and communicate with her family and other deaf members of her society. Her parents, particularly her father, are trying to restrain her from getting a device that will help her excel in both "worlds"
The one thing that truly irritates me about her fathers decision is the fact that he is making a decision for his daughter instead of her for herself. He is trying to take control of her life because he thinks he knows what is best for her. Granted she is only five but if she understands the cultures, risks, and outcome who is to say she cant get the implant. Her father "turned out" just fine and that is great for him but the possibilities she would have with the implant are far more than with out it.
If I was her father, the moment I found out she was deaf I would have singed the papers to get the surgery done as soon as possible.
Wednesday, October 7, 2009
Subscribe to:
Post Comments (Atom)
6 comments:
I completely agree with you. I think its selfish of the parents to try and force her not to get an implant. If it works it could offer her so many more opportunities than if she remained deaf.
I totally agree that it's selfish to hold her back from communicating with the hearing world if that's what she wants. It's unfair to keep her isolated.
I can't say I feel the same. As people who have been hearing our entire lives, we feel that it would be wrong to prevent somebody from having this opportunity. Perhaps so, but it's also the goal of parents to be able to relate to their children and I think this is what Peter was trying to do.
I agree with you that it is ridiculous how they chose to isolate her in an all deaf community, when this community is clearly dying out. I think that Peter Sr. (the grandfather) was right in saying that this is abuse of Heather in not giving her the implant.
I agree with you that it is ridiculous how they chose to isolate her in an all deaf community, when this community is clearly dying out. I think that Peter Sr. (the grandfather) was right in saying that this is abuse of Heather in not giving her the implant.
This is a really tough decision to make--I couldn't imagine what Heather's parents were going through! Even as hearing people, we can see that we all have different opinions on the situation. Each individual should decide what's the best fit for them.
Post a Comment