Vietnam and Madison, WI are worlds apart in ever aspect of geography and culture. But during the Vietnam war, they were related. Madison students were infuriated about the war as I am sure many if not most Vietnamese were as well. It is hard to believe that Madison had such an impact on the country and the way it felt about the war at that time. Growing up in a suburb just outside Madison and never hearing about these riots was a big shock to me.
Regarding Lampert Smith's article, I think that a social revolution and/or student protests are not impossible. I think that the only thing that would happen would be an increase in the number of followers of the protests. The article states that with the technology today, people are boxed into their own worlds. Well this is very true but prank text messages get around an entire high school in less than 5 min. A war protest movement is a text message away. If you add this mode of information passing to television advertisements to facebook groups to posters in the hall ways of the school and by lunch time you have 5,000 kids ready to take on the Madison police...Again.
Now for Vietnam. I have a pretty pro-war bias due to the fact that my grandfather was in the war and his stories often describe Vietnam as a war that was more or less needed. Granted his staff Sargent probably told him that was the only story he could tell but none the less, that is what I believe. On the topic of DOW manufacturing, I find myself on a fence. No I don't want to see children with their skin melted off or face's half deteriorated, but it was a war. I feel bad for saying it almost but war, is in fact war. When it comes down to your life or someones who is trying to kill you, many would choose to take the other's life.
For Frodo!
Thursday, October 22, 2009
Wednesday, October 7, 2009
Sound and Fury
During the end of last week and the beginning of this week we watched the documentary Sound and Fury. I enjoyed the film and the actions portrayed in it but there were some things I absolutely hated.
Heather is a five year old girl who can already talk and communicate with her family and other deaf members of her society. Her parents, particularly her father, are trying to restrain her from getting a device that will help her excel in both "worlds"
The one thing that truly irritates me about her fathers decision is the fact that he is making a decision for his daughter instead of her for herself. He is trying to take control of her life because he thinks he knows what is best for her. Granted she is only five but if she understands the cultures, risks, and outcome who is to say she cant get the implant. Her father "turned out" just fine and that is great for him but the possibilities she would have with the implant are far more than with out it.
If I was her father, the moment I found out she was deaf I would have singed the papers to get the surgery done as soon as possible.
Heather is a five year old girl who can already talk and communicate with her family and other deaf members of her society. Her parents, particularly her father, are trying to restrain her from getting a device that will help her excel in both "worlds"
The one thing that truly irritates me about her fathers decision is the fact that he is making a decision for his daughter instead of her for herself. He is trying to take control of her life because he thinks he knows what is best for her. Granted she is only five but if she understands the cultures, risks, and outcome who is to say she cant get the implant. Her father "turned out" just fine and that is great for him but the possibilities she would have with the implant are far more than with out it.
If I was her father, the moment I found out she was deaf I would have singed the papers to get the surgery done as soon as possible.
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)