Wednesday, September 9, 2009
Critical Analysis on Non-Fiction Books
The critical reviews that we did in class were, i found, extremely hard to do on non-ficton books. it was not that critical reviews are hard for me but to find an origional argument about facts is hard to do. It seemed as if we were supposed to challenge the authors facts he or she had in their writting. in order to make an origional argument (if i even began to make one) i had to really push to find something i could spin off as an argument. Malcom Gladwell in his critical review of TKAM had an amazing structure and meening to his piece but he also (not to mention used the most studied book in High School) had a fictional story that had an argument to refute. it was not hard to find an alternative argument in that book or in his writting because fiction books present you with possibilities that non-fiction books dont. so on the topic of the critical reviews i am hesitent to say i liked the project. I like to premise of it, just not the requirement of the non-fiction part.
Subscribe to:
Post Comments (Atom)
5 comments:
TJ- Watch your spelling buddy!! haha It is also extremely annoying that your comment box pops up so it's difficult to skim the blog and comment at the same time! You're not the only one who had a hard time on the critical analysis...I think we all did!
When I tried to leave you a comment, a pop-up appeared and instructed me to leave a comment.
I find this TERRIBLY annoying.
I'm pretty sure that right now everyone is writing about how much the critical analysis sucked :).
I also wrote about how Malcom had it easy when he wrote about To Kill a Mocking Bird.
I don't want to be repetitive because Chelsea already noted this, but there are lots of grammar and spelling errors. Maybe you should click the spell check button before posting next time. :) Just a thought
There's a spell check button?
Anyhow.
I agree. I liked them but it was difficult to do on a nonficiton book because TKAM has some underlying message to it. It's harder to connect real life to real life than fiction to real life.
There's a spell check button?
Anyhow.
I agree. I liked them but it was difficult to do on a nonficiton book because TKAM has some underlying message to it. It's harder to connect real life to real life than fiction to real life.
Post a Comment